Ntev tom qab nws tuag hauv 2003, zaj lus hais tias Dr. Robert Atkins "tuag ntawm nws txoj kev noj zaub mov" tsis ua li cas. Kev txhawj xeeb tshaj nws cov low-carb , noj cov zaub mov muaj roj yog ib lub ntsiab lus ntawm kev sib cav tswv yim ntau xyoo thiab nws txoj kev tuag ua tsawg rau kev ntxub lawv.
Cov lus dag uas hais txog Dr. Atkins 'tuag tau raug muab los ntawm pawg vegan pawg kws kho mob rau cov kws kho mob thiab cov neeg thiab lwm tus neeg.
Lub suab sib tw ua tau zoo ua ntej nws tuag, Dr. Dean Ornish, yog cov neeg. Nws tau sau ib daim ntawv tawm tswv yim hauv Lub Peb Hlis 2007 tsab xov xwm ntawm Xov Xwm uas muaj qee cov tsis muaj tseeb, uas tom qab ntawd tau muab khaws cia los ntawm magazine *.
Dr. Atkins tuag li cas thiab nws noj nws txoj sia? Cov lus teb yog qhov nyuaj thiab nws yog qhov zoo tshaj plaws los soj ntsuam cov lus tseeb ntawm nws lub neej thiab kev tuag es tsis txhob mloog cov lus xaiv.
Ntev npaum li cas Atkins hauv nws noj?
Dr. Atkins yog ib tug kws kho mob uas xub tsim nws cov khoom noj thaum xyoo 1970. Nws tau ntseeg tias qhov tshaj ntawm carbohydrate muaj kev tsis zoo los ntawm nws cov neeg mob lub cev thiab qhov hnyav.
Atkins tau luam tawm thawj phau ntawv, "Dr. Atkins Diet Revolution" nyob rau xyoo 1972, thiab ntau zaus ntau xyoo dhau los hais tias nws tau ua raws li nws txoj hau kev. Nws yog pej xeem, pom hauv TV ntau zaus thiab muaj ntau cov duab coj. Los ntawm txhua tus account, nws noj qab nyob zoo thiab haum rau feem ntau ntawm cov sij hawm ntawd.
Cardiomyopathy
Xyoo 2000, Dr. Atkins tau ua tus mob cardiomyopathy, ib lub plawv mob tsis zoo uas muaj ntau yam ua rau.
Nws xav tias nws tus mob cardiomyopathy yog vim yog mob viral. Nws tus kws kho mob tau teev lus thaum lub sij hawm uas tsis muaj pov thawj tias nws noj nws cov khoom noj. Nws cov hlab ntsha coronary tau qhia tias tau soj ntsuam thaum lub sij hawm ntawd thiab pom tias tsis muaj kev txwv ntawm cov blockages.
Cardiomyopathy ua rau tus neeg ntawd muaj lub plawv nres (lub plawv nres), uas tau tshwm sim rau Dr. Atkins ob xyoo tom qab nws kuaj.
Ntxiv dua thiab, lub plawv nres tsis tau xav tias nws yuav noj cov zaub mov vim nws tus kab mob coronary ntshiab. Nws tus kws kho mob tau hais tias (tsis yog cov kab mob cardiomyopathy), Atkins tau "ib qho kev mob plawv zoo dua."
Puas Atkins Rog?
William Leith, tus kws sau ntawv uas xam phaj Dr. Atkins ib ntus ntawm nws lub plawv nres, nws tau hais tias "nws zoo nkaus li nyob rau hauv 6 feet siab thiab tsis txog 200 lbs - tsis yuag, tsis nyias, tab sis mas nws yeej tsis rog." Ib daim ntawv qhia los ntawm tus kws kho mob lub lag luam, Atkins Nutritionals, tau hais tias nws ntaus pob ntaus pob sib tw thiab nws qhov hnyav tau nquag saib, thiab hauv lub xyoo ua ntej nws tuag nws tseem tshuav qis tshaj 195, thiab rau siab txog 6 feet.
Ib daim ntawv qhia txog kev kho mob thaum nws nkag mus rau hauv tsev kho mob, uas tom qab ntawd tau txais pej xeem los ntawm nws tus poj ntsuam, hais tias nws yog 195 phaus ntawm kev nkag mus rau tsev kho mob. Qhov no yuav ua rau nws lub cev qhov Performance index (BMI) ntawm 26, uas yog qhov ntau tshaj qhov kev txiav txim siab yog "qhov hnyav." Feem ntau, nws yog me ntsis nyhav dhau.
Atkins 'tuag
Lub Plaub Hlis 8, 2003, thaum muaj hnub nyoog 72 xyoos, Dr. Atkins poob rau hauv cov dej khov thaum mus kev ua haujlwm. Thaum lub caij nplooj zeeg, nws ntaus nws lub taub hau thiab qhov no ua rau los ntshav ntawm nws lub hlwb. Nws poob nco ntsoov ntawm txoj kev mus rau lub tsev kho mob, qhov uas nws tau siv ob lub lis piam hauv kev tu xyuas mob heev.
Nws lub cev zuj zus sai sai thiab nws raug mob loj heev.
Thaum lub sij hawm no, nws lub cev tau ceev cia ib qho dej loj heev. Nws lub cev nyhav thaum tuag 258 phaus (dua, cov ntaub ntawv hais tias nws yog 195 xyoo thaum nkag mus hauv tsev kho mob). Nws daim ntawv pov thawj hais tias qhov ua rau kev tuag yog "blunt impact injury of head with epidural hematoma."
Nram qab no, Dr. Richard Fleming, tus kws kho mob hauv Nebraska paub tias yog Anti-Atkins thiab kev koom nrog cov kws kho mob rau cov kws kho mob yuav tsum tau thov Dr. Atkins 'cov ntaub ntawv kho mob. Cov no yuav tsum tsis tau raug tso tawm tiam sis tau ua yuam kev xa tawm.
Tus kws ntsuam xyuas kev kuaj mob tau sau ib daim ntawv sau tseg tias Atkins muaj keeb kwm ntawm myocardial infarction (plawv nres), congestive heart failure, thiab kub siab (sau "h / o MI, CHF, HTN"). Pawg neeg saum no tau ua ntau qhov no thiab pib qhov lus xaiv ntawd Atkins tau "tuag ntawm nws cov zaub mov noj."
Muaj ib xyoos tom qab nws tuag, nws tus poj ntsuam tso tawm cov lus uas nws tau hu ua "cov neeg tsis ua tsis ncaj" rau kev ua hauj lwm rau kev dag txog nws tus txiv. Thaj li no, cov neeg no tseem muaj kev ntsuas zoo vim tias qhov tsis sib haum xeeb tseem nyob rau hnub no.
Lo Lus Ntawm
Qhov tseeb ua rau Dr. Atkins 'tuag, raws li cov lus ceeb toom, yog lub taub hau raug mob uas nws txhawb nqa, tsis yog qhov kev pab cuam nws tsim. Txawm li cas los xij, cov lus tseeb yuav tsum tsis txhob siv los txiav txim siab los yog tsis yog Atkins noj zaub mov zoo rau koj. Nrog koj tus kws kho mob tham, tus kws qhia noj zaub mov, lossis tus neeg saib kev noj zaub mov thiab nug cov lus nug uas koj muaj. Lawv tuaj yeem muab cov lus qhia zoo tshaj plaws rau koj cov hom phiaj xiam oob khab.
* Nyob rau lub Peb Hlis 2007, Xov Tshaj Xov Xwm tau tshaj tawm cov lus qhuab qhia, "Ib zaj dab neeg ntawm zaj dab neeg no muaj nyob rau hauv cov xwm txheej ntawm txoj kev tuag ntawm Dr. Robert Atkins." Newsweek regrets qhov yuam kev. "
> Source:
> Kleinfield NR. Tsuas yog Tua tus Kws Kho Mob Phem Tua, Thiab Dab Tsi Tshaj Dab Tsi? New York zaug . Ob Hlis 11, 2004.
> Leith W. Lub Xyoo Nyaug Tshaj: Kev lees paub ntawm kev noj mov. London, UK; Bloomsbury Publishing: 2005.
> Rowland R. Atkins Diet Author Home tom qab mob ntes. CNN. Lub Plaub Hlis 25, 2002.
> Teicholz N. Lub Rivalry ntawm Atkins thiab Ornish. Nyob rau hauv: Lub Taub Dag Zog Rog: Vim Li Cas Butter, Nqaij, thiab Cheese Muaj Kev Noj Qab Nyob Zoo. New York, NY; Simon & Schuster: 2014.